Why you should almost never rewrite code a graphical guide. Software development is a chaotic activity, therefore the implemented structure of systems tends to stray from the planned structure as determined by the architecture, analysis and design. Making all posts independent makes it easy to pick. Refactoring is the process of altering an applications source code without changing its external behavior. The importance of refactoring when moving to the cloud. Joel purra has been one of the most positive influences for me as a developer. Refactoring is intended to improve the design, structure, andor implementation of the software its nonfunctional attributes, while preserving its functionality. I disagree vehemently with joels article on rewriting. During this time, netscape sat by, helplessly, as their market share plummeted. His teaching skills come from his positive attitude, patience, and his extraordinary skill set in software development.
Refactoring is the process of changing a software system in such a way that it does not alter the external behavior of the code yet improves its internal structure. Joel spolsky references several big company rewrites that failed but did not kill. About a year before joel wrote things you should never do, martin fowler published his popular. Several software engineers, such as joel spolsky have warned against total rewrites, especially. What is refactoring and what is only modifying code. Making all posts independent makes it easy to pick up the book every now and then, read one, and move on. For my day job, im the cofounder and ceo of stack overflow, the largest online community for programmers to learn, share their knowledge, and level up. Keshta department of computer engineering king fahd university of petroleum and minerals dhahran, saudi arabia abstractthe objective of software refactoring is to improve the software products quality by improving its performance and understandability. Likewise, software professionals need to be open about the costs of refactoring. The old mantra build one to throw away is dangerous when applied to large scale commercial applications. Introduction to software engineeringtestingrefactoring. The upside to this is that all along the way, you still have working software that you can change.
A rewrite in computer programming is the act or result of reimplementing a large portion of. Improving a piece of softwares internal structure without altering its external behavior. In the words of martin fowler, the father of the code smell notion, refactoring is the process of changing a software system to improve its internal structure without altering. See the complete profile on linkedin and discover joels connections and jobs at similar companies. The purpose of code refactoring is to improve some of the nonfunctional properties of the code, such as readability, complexity, maintainability and extensibility. In this context, refactoring could be favored since the product is always marketready and refactoring can consistently improve the quality to sustain the product for a longer period. Dive into refactoring teaches you how to properly deal with legacy code, how to identify ugly code and how to clean it safely. These problems can be solved, one at a time, by carefully moving code, refactoring, changing interfaces. Apr 25, 2016 in this context, refactoring could be favored since the product is always marketready and refactoring can consistently improve the quality to sustain the product for a longer period. Three years is an awfully long time in the internet world. In computer programming and software design, code refactoring is the process of restructuring existing computer codechanging the factoringwithout changing its external behavior. Backwater businesses as well as big corporate outfits just dont care about this joel fella and his nifty. It should be practiced early and often to help maintain and improve code quality over time.
There is no real limit on the number of letters that unicode can define and in fact they have gone beyond 65,536 so not every unicode letter can really be squeezed into two bytes, but that was a myth anyway. What joel spolsky, martin fowler, and michael feathers have taught us about rewrites vs refactoring submitted 2 years ago by friendlytuna 48 comments. Almost two decades ago, joel spolsky excoriated netscape for rewriting their. Refactoring doesnt change the observable behavior of the software. Aiming for more is idealistic but not realistic at least outside the big software hotbeds. User joel purra software engineering stack exchange. Software refactoring is an effective approach for improving software structure. Improving a piece of software s internal structure without altering its external behavior. Adding features, refactoring systems, building greenfield projects and mvps from scratch. Bill tomlinson wednesday, february 4, 2004 someone mentioned refactoring support in ides recently. I take issue with joels recent bathtub refactoring essay. Why refactoring code is almost always better than rewriting it.
Feb 23, 2015 118 videos play all software development process. View joel trottierheberts profile on linkedin, the worlds largest professional community. In the spirit of refactoring, i set out a few rules for this exercise. The course covers 21 smells of bad code and 66 refactoring techniques to fix them. Sep 09, 2015 app refactoring takes the user interface of existing applications and uses special remote protocols and software to transform them into mobilefriendly, modern apps. Joel louie llorente software engineer factset linkedin. Adding new features, refactoring old systems, building entire greenfield projects and mvps from scratch. Part 3 of 3 udacity requirements engineering lecture 2. What joel spolsky, martin fowler, and michael feathers have. According to martin fowler, refactoring is the process of changing a software system in such a way that it does not alter the external behavior of the code yet improves its internal structure.
Yes, sometimes it makes more sense to gradually refactor your legacy code. Jakub pilimon talks about bluegreen refactoring with parallel models. Providing a comprehensible format for the innerstate of software system structure, data models, and intracomponents dependencies is a critical element to form a highlevel. Were a long way from having all the good tools we need in most programming environments you cant even do a simple transformation like changing the name of a variable and having all the references to it. When evaluating the refactoring capabilities of these ides you need to get a complete list of which refactorings the ide supports and map it against the ones that you commonly use. Checklist of refactoring done right way the code should become cleaner. A survey of software refactoring tom mens, member, ieee, and tom tourwe abstract this paper provides an extensive overview of existing research in the field of software refactoring. Each month, more than 40 million professional and aspiring programmers visit stack overflow to ask and answer questions and find better jobs. Refactoring can extend the life of source code, preventing it from. And if users found the onpremises version clunky and difficult to navigate, replatforming wouldnt change that experience.
Refactoring is changing the internal structure of the code without modifying its external behavior. Things you should never do, part i joel on software. Code refactoring is a disciplined way to restructure code, undertaken in order to improve some of the nonfunctional attributes of the software. Its largely invisible work, and if you do it right, the end user will never know the difference. Refactor vs rewrite refactoring for software design smells. Although i often agree with joel, this is one subject where i have a difference of opinion. A piece of software is typically rewritten when one or more of the following apply. Code refactoring activities are secured with software intelligence when using tools and technics providing data about algorithms and sequences of code execution. I take issue with joel s recent bathtub refactoring essay. Nov 24, 2009 the goal of refactoring and rewriting is to improve the sanity of the system by improving the code readability, structure and clarity.
And on diverse and occasionally related matters that will prove of interest to software developers, designers, and managers, and to those who, whether by good fortune or ill luck, work with them in some capacity spolsky, joel on. I am passionate about people, i love scalability, great user experience, thoughtful security, and elegant design patterns. Read about when refactoring the architecture might be a good idea. The goal of refactoring and rewriting is to improve the sanity of the system by improving the code readability, structure and clarity. Refactoring is a great way to do this, a step at a time. Refactored apps can take advantage of their desktop. Although undesirable from a software engineering point of view, such systems are common in practice due to business pressures, developer turnover and code entropy. With joels newest book, more joel on software, youll get an even better not to mention updated feast of joels opinions and impressions on software development, software design, running a software business, and so much more. Painless functional specifications joel on software. Factor factor one of two or more quantities that divides a given quantity without a remainder, e.
At the same time, its my experience that a joel score of 4 is pretty much as good as its ever going to be, in any company ive ever worked in. Joel louie ay may 2 mga trabaho na nakalista sa kanilang profile. Jan 25, 2002 i take issue with joel s recent bathtub refactoring essay. Dharmesh shah, why you should almost never rewrite your software. Software folks are generally in their 20s and didnt see them the first time around. Refactoring should be done as a series of small changes, each of which makes the existing code slightly better while still leaving the program in working order.
App refactoring takes the user interface of existing applications and uses special remote protocols and software to transform them into mobilefriendly, modern apps. Code refactoring is the process of changing a computer programs internal structure without modifying its external functional behavior or existing functionality, in order to improve internal nonfunctional properties of the software, for example to improve code readability, to simplify code structure, to change code to adhere to a given. Typically, this is done by applying series of refactorings, each of which is a usually tiny change in a computer programs source code that does not modify its functional requirements. Incurs a shortterm timework cost to reap longterm benefits a longterm investment in the overall quality of your system. The absolute minimum every software developer absolutely. Apr 06, 2000 the old mantra build one to throw away is dangerous when applied to large scale commercial applications. If you think that the old software is a piece of crap that doesnt deliver any value then think again. Joel spolsky wrote a post back in 2000 about netscapes decision to rewrite their browser from scratch in the late 1990s. Joel trottierhebert software developer bitbox usa linkedin. As an independent, privatelyowned company, weve been making customers happy since the turn of the century. Motivation for software architecture refactoring software architecture is constantly shifting and changing during development. Nov 14, 2017 companies still had to write a big check for the software license every year. Primarily shortterm contracts 03 months with option to extend, optionally parttime 840 hours per week, mostly working remotely.
Refactoring, way for software maintenance madhulika arora1, dr. An interesting new area is refactoring tools, which is just a fancy word for programs that do some of this stuff automatically. Lessons from 6 software rewrite stories herb caudill medium. Motivation for software architecture refactoring dzone devops. If you are writing code experimentally, you may want to rip up the function you wrote last week when you think of a better algorithm. There are maybe 40 posts and the book is about 350 pages. Mar 19, 2020 jakub pilimon talks about bluegreen refactoring with parallel models.
You may want to refactor a class to make it easier to use. When a software system is successful, there is always a need to keep enhancing it, to fix problems and add new features. You cant refactor without the tests, but the tests cant exist without refactoring. However, refactoring is fundamentally different to rewriting. Refactoring requires that the original desktop applications still run and be maintained, which brings an added bonus. Thinking about refactoring when moving to the cloud. With joel s newest book, more joel on software, youll get an even better not to mention updated feast of joel s opinions and impressions on software development, software design, running a software business, and so much more. See the complete profile on linkedin and discover joels. And on diverse and occasionally related matters that will prove of interest to. Of course, were all guilty of putting this off when deadlines and management expectations force us to choose between just having something working on time or improving upon your. Tingnan ang profile ni joel louie llorente sa linkedin, ang pinakamalaking komunidad ng propesyunal sa buong mundo. Tingnan ang kompletong profile sa linkedin at matuklasan ang mga koneksyon at trabaho sa kaparehong mga kompanya ni joel louie. We share what weve learned about how to make great software, both by writing about our ideas and by creating products, like fogbugz, trello and gomix, that help others make great technology.
A big ball of mud is a software system that lacks a perceivable architecture. Again, you can apply it to a design system instead of a software system. But the nature of a codebase makes a big difference on how easy it is to make these changes. Good software architecture is essential for system extension and maintenance. I also founded fog creek software, one of the most influential small tech companies in the world. This blog post from 2004 called refactoring vs rearchitecting vs redesign vs rewriting takes an interesting perspective, showing that refactoring is more about keeping things simple and flexible than it is about getting things right.
Companies still had to write a big check for the software license every year. This comes back to the main point of the first part of this article. Joel on software is a collection of joels blog posts. Reasons to refactor georgia tech software development. Refactoring is an important step in the software development process. I demand the immediate return of the sage, sane, wise joel spolsky of. My experience is that refactoring in place of ground up redesign of applications leads to progressively more and more time refactoring, leaving less and less time for new features. For example, if a programmer wants to add new functionality to a program, he may decide to refactor the program first to simplify the addition of new functionality in order to prevent software entropy.
103 686 1015 1534 818 1311 1463 256 696 117 308 1428 123 1300 1470 347 757 1373 477 888 1086 115 1549 304 1121 420 343 508 1307 772 325 739